Transgender youth reemerge as statehouse focal point in Utah
Republican lawmakers argue the government needs to regulate the growing field of transgender health care to protect children. LGBTQ families and their advocates argue decision-making should be left to doctors and patients.
By SAM METZ Associated Press
SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — Utah lawmakers wasted no time this week before returning to an issue that has become a popular topic in GOP-led statehouses: Trying to limit medical options doctors are allowed to provide transgender youth.
On the second day of the legislative session, a committee began considering a policy that would stop minors from receiving gender-affirming health care — including surgery or puberty blockers. They also began considering a proposal to require schools to notify parents when kids want to change which pronouns they go by, and another that would limit when transgender people under 18 can change the sex listed on their birth certificates.
Each measure advanced through the committee on a 5-2 party line vote.
The proposals reflect how lawmakers in red states continue to make matters related to gender, sexuality and youth central to their legislative agenda. As LGBTQ Americans become increasingly visible in popular culture, some social conservatives have rallied around issues such as the bathrooms that transgender kids can use, sports teams they are allowed to play on and the health care their doctors can prescribe.
This year, 11 states have introduced proposals that would enact restrictions on doctors from prescribing puberty blockers, hormones or surgery to transgender kids and teens, regardless of what their parents want. Republicans on Tuesday introduced a transgender health care proposal in South Dakota, where one supportive lawmaker called puberty a "natural cure" for gender dysphoria.
State Sen. Mike Kennedy, a Republican family doctor sponsoring Utah's proposal, said it didn't make sense that health care policy related to gender and youth — which is at times reversible and other times irreversible — would be subject to no government oversight.
He acknowledged the topic was emotional for the families of transgender youth, yet said it was government's responsibility to address issues of children's consent and development.
"Caring for our children does not mean riding the latest radical wave," he said. "We must ask questions: Does the child understand the long-term ramifications of their decision?"
"We can't allow social policy to outpace science," he added, arguing for more research on gender dysphoria and noting how medical fields in countries such as Finland and Sweden have tightened regulations governing transgender youth health care.
Questions about transgender youth and their health care dovetail with another growing Republican priority: parental rights. Jeri Brummett, a transgender woman and member of the Salt Lake County Republican Party, called the proposal excessive governmental intervention into individual medical decisions.
The bill, she said, "purports to protect transgender minors from their doctors and parents, yet its real effect is to place this Legislature and our state government between parents, their children and their doctors."
Greg Walker, a Utah parent whose daughter has identified as transgender "since she could talk," said it was disheartening to see the health care decisions his family and their doctors have made politicized.
At each juncture – before she went on puberty blockers or estrogen, for example — the Walkers and their doctors thoroughly deliberated and relied on experts like the American Academy of Pediatrics to understand "the risks of doing it and not doing it."
Walker said he was particularly concerned about the disproportionately high suicide rates for transgender youth and of the potential harm that could result in the absence of treatment.
"As a parent. my first priority is to take care of my child and make sure my child's safe," Walker said.
In Utah, where a majority of residents and politicians are members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, lawmakers have for years focused heavily on social issues, including pornography and alcohol. Last year, the Republican-supermajority Legislature enacted a ban on transgender kids in girls sports. It was subsequently challenged in court and put on pause. While the case undergoes review, a commission of experts is making eligibility decisions for transgender youth.
One concern that arose during discussions about eligibility decisions was the use of birth certificates to verify athletes' sex because transgender people routinely apply to change them. The Utah Supreme Court affirmed their right to make the changes two years ago.
State Sen. Dan McCay, a Republican who led the charge for last year's youth sports ban, said limiting the changes would help Utah enforce its youth sports policy and only affect minors. Opponents who testified at the hearing said identification document changes were an individual liberty issue and deeply emotional for transgender people who don't want to out themselves on a daily basis.