How The Pandemic Turned An Introvert Into A Voice For Gig Workers

Dec 26, 2020
Originally published on December 28, 2020 5:43 am

Updated at 3:05 p.m. ET

Willy Solis never saw himself as an activist.

"I'm an introvert, extreme introvert," he said. "That's my nature."

But 2020 changed that — like so many other things.

The coronavirus pandemic drove many people to recognize gig work as "essential" for the first time, but the crisis also revealed the stark disparities between jobs that come with security and benefits and gig work, which does not.

And Solis, the introvert, became a voice for thousands of gig workers, leading calls for better treatment and wages. He organized walkouts and protests over pay and safety concerns at Shipt, the grocery delivery app owned by Target. He also joined the Gig Workers Collective, a group pushing for better treatment of workers across apps, including Instacart and Lyft.

No one was more surprised by this newfound activism than Solis himself.

"It's taken me to a place where I never thought that I'd be," he said.

The 42-year-old resident of Denton, Texas, delivers for Shipt and other apps. While he had some frustrations with gig work before the pandemic, he enjoyed the flexibility it promised and the opportunity to control his own time.

But then in January, Shipt started changing the way it calculates pay for many of the hundreds of thousands of workers who pluck items off the shelves of stores like Target and Kroger and deliver them to customers' homes.

Solis had been commiserating with fellow workers — whom Shipt calls "shoppers" — for months. But that pay change pushed him over the edge.

"In a two-week period, I talked to over 600 shoppers," he said. "And then next thing I know, I'm finding myself talking to national media."

When the pandemic hit just a few weeks later, it made everything worse. Shipt shoppers struggled to get protective equipment, like masks and gloves.

Solis was on his phone from morning to night, connecting with other workers in Facebook groups and messaging apps. Soon he was in touch with thousands of people.

The first walkout came in April. Shoppers refused to accept orders. They did it again in May, July and October. A few also protested outside Target's headquarters in Minneapolis and Shipt's main office in Birmingham, Ala.

Organizing is now a huge part of Solis' life. While sitting in his car waiting for orders to show up on the different apps he works for, he responds to tweets and Facebook messages, checking in with fellow shoppers.

This summer, he was laid up with COVID-19. Still, he kept going — talking to reporters and keeping tabs on the organizing work from his sickbed.

"I know that that sounds crazy," he said.

His efforts have forced change. After Solis and fellow activists raised repeated complaints, Shipt acknowledged in August that some workers were not getting the tips customers paid.

The company said it was "a system glitch that caused a very small number of tips from being transferred to shoppers." It paid the missing tips and added an extra $5 for every affected shopper.

Shipt said workers' feedback is important to the company. "We encourage shoppers to speak freely to Shipt about their shopper experience through multiple feedback channels we offer. We also have teams dedicated to hearing, logging and sharing shopper feedback we receive among the company," spokeswoman Danielle Schumann told NPR in a statement.

The company says the new pay model did not change shoppers' average pay. A study by MIT researchers reached the same conclusion, but found pay varies widely, with 41% of workers in its survey earning less under Shipt's new system.

Solis still thinks the pay is too low. And, he says, the work is hard. He waits a long time to get orders, since so many people affected by the pandemic have signed up for gig work to make ends meet.

"The reality is that I could go out and find another job and bring myself up into a better financial situation," he said. But he feels he is able to speak out, while others cannot take that risk. "I decided to go ahead and stick it out as long as I possibly can."

Solis doesn't want to relive his battle with the virus or spread it to others. So he uses a lot of disinfecting wipes and hand sanitizer — more than the 6 ounces a month that Shipt supplies. (The company provides free reusable masks, wipes and hand sanitizer to workers who say they want it. It also makes free masks and gloves available at Target stores.) And he works just enough hours to cover his bills. Christmas with his four kids was a low-key affair this year.

Solis says the trade-offs are worth it. He found his voice.

"It's beyond one person and one family," he said. "My story is everybody's story. And there's thousands of people that I speak for."

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

DON GONYEA, HOST:

In 2020, gig work became essential, from delivering groceries to driving for Uber. But that essential work doesn't come with the security of most other jobs. And the pandemic has only exacerbated that inequality. That prompted one of those workers, Willy Solis, to speak up. Here's what he told NPR's Shannon Bond in April.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED NPR BROADCAST)

WILLY SOLIS: I have never done organizing in my life. I see myself falling into this as a freak accident.

GONYEA: Shannon caught up with him recently to hear how this year has gone.

SHANNON BOND: For Willy Solis, many days start like this, in his driveway in Denton, Texas.

SOLIS: It's around 9:54 in the morning, just came out to my car - going to jump on the Shipt app to see if I can find a couple of orders.

(SOUNDBITE OF MACHINE BEEPING)

BOND: He recorded the sounds of a typical day as a shopper for a Shipt, the delivery service owned by Target. He gathers products on store shelves and drives them to customer's homes. Solis was attracted to gig work by the promise of flexibility and controlling his own time, then Shipt changed the way it calculates pay. That was the last straw for Solis, who had been discussing his frustrations with other Shipt workers, known as shoppers, for months.

SOLIS: In a two-week period, I talked to over 600 shoppers, and, I mean, I was tearing up. And then next thing I know, I'm finding myself talking to national media.

BOND: The pandemic made things even worse. The workers struggled to get protective equipment like masks and gloves. Solis was on his phone morning and night, connecting with workers on Facebook groups and messaging apps. Soon he was in touch with thousands of people. They organized walkouts, refusing to accept orders. A few protested outside Target's headquarters in Minneapolis. No one was more surprised by this newfound activism than Solis himself.

SOLIS: It's taken me to a place where I never thought that I'd be. I'm an introvert - extreme introvert. My natural - or that's - my nature is very, very introvert.

BOND: Organizing is now a huge part of Solis' life. He does it while waiting for orders to show up on the app.

SOLIS: I responded to several people, responded to a couple of tweets, responded to a couple of Facebook messages - you know, just try to make it a productive morning since I'm not seeming to get any orders.

BOND: He even caught COVID, and he still kept going.

SOLIS: I continue to organize from the bed. And I know that that sounds crazy, but that's what I did. And talking to reporters and doing the things that I was doing to try and get our word out while still working on trying to recover from COVID, it wasn't fun.

BOND: His organizing has forced change, getting Shipt to acknowledge some workers were not getting the tips they had earned. And the company then made them whole. But Solis says the work is hard. He waits a long time to get orders since so many people affected by the pandemic have signed up for gig work to make ends meet. And the pay is low.

SOLIS: The reality is that I could go out and find another job and bring myself up into a better financial situation for me personally. However, we need people to be speaking out. And there's so many people that cannot speak out. And they're afraid to speak out. You know, I decided to go ahead and stick it out as long as I possibly can.

BOND: So today, that means taking precautions. Solis doesn't want to relive his battle with COVID or spread it to others.

SOLIS: As soon as I get to my car, I will put some more hand sanitizer on my hands.

BOND: He says he's learned to live with the trade-offs, like only working enough to cover essential bills and a low-key Christmas with his kids because he has a bigger mission.

SOLIS: It's beyond one person and one family. It's like my story is everybody's story. And there's thousands of people that I speak for.

BOND: In 2020, Solis found his voice. Shannon Bond, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.